Skip to content
90 daysto judge an agency
Practical guide

How to choose a Shopify agency you won't regret in three months

By Miguel Camacho, founder of Hipervínculo · Published November 19, 2026

Picking an agency is a decision about money and time. A good one saves you from expensive mistakes. A bad one costs you ad spend, months of sales and sometimes access to your own accounts. This guide gives you the questions, the red flags and the criteria to compare agencies calmly, even if you end up not choosing us.

Short answer. Pick an agency that covers the store, ads, SEO and tracking, or works closely with whoever does. It should measure success with your net Shopify sales, keep every account in your name, put its pricing formula in writing and never guarantee results. Then judge the first 90 days against a clear baseline, not promises.

What a Shopify agency should do

"Shopify agency" can mean very different things: a studio that only designs stores, a team that only runs ads, or a shop that does it all. Before you compare, decide what you need. A store that sells consistently usually needs four areas working together:

The store

Design, speed, clear product pages and a checkout without friction. This is where you win or lose every visit you paid for.

Shopify store design

Advertising

Meta to introduce the product to new people and Google to catch the ones already searching for it, with creative that gets refreshed before it burns out.

Meta Ads for Shopify

SEO

Collections, product pages and content that bring in organic traffic without paying for every click. It's slower, but it compounds.

Shopify SEO

Tracking

Pixel, Conversions API and GA4 set up properly and checked against real Shopify orders. Without it, every other decision is made blind.

Shopify tracking

Not every agency has to do all four. But if one only handles ads, someone still has to own the store and the tracking, because the ads depend on both.

The questions to ask

Bring these questions to every call. Vague answers are answers too.

  • Whose name are the accounts in? The store, the Meta Business Manager, the Google Ads account and GA4 should all be yours. The agency gets partner or collaborator access.
  • What number do you measure success against? You want to hear your net Shopify sales and your margin, not just the ROAS each platform reports.
  • Who actually works on my account? Ask who builds the campaigns, who makes the creative, and who you talk to when something breaks.
  • What would you do in the first 30 days? A good agency talks about checking tracking, the store and the account structure before raising budgets.
  • How do you charge, and what happens if I want out? Ask about the minimum commitment, the cancellation notice and what you get handed at the end.
  • Do you have results in my category or at my size? Ask for numbers with context: where the store started, over what period, and how it was measured.
  • How often do you report, and what's in the report? A useful report shows sales, spend, ROAS, what was tested and what's next.
Red flags

What should make you think twice

  • Ad accounts in the agency's name. If you leave, you lose the history, the audiences and everything the campaigns learned.
  • Long contracts with expensive exits. A locked-in year or steep cancellation fees keep you tied down even when there are no results.
  • Vanity-metric reports. Impressions, reach and clicks with no sales, no margin and no comparison to Shopify.
  • No access to your data. If all you get are screenshots or the agency's own dashboard, you can't verify anything.
  • Guaranteed results. Nobody controls the market, the competition or your product. Anyone guaranteeing a ROAS is promising something that isn't only up to them.
  • Ad spend routed through the agency with no detail. If you don't see the Meta and Google invoices in your name, you don't know what was really spent.

Pricing models compared

No model is good or bad on its own. Each one nudges the agency toward something different, and it's worth knowing what.

ModelHow it worksUpsideWatch out for
HourlyYou pay for hours worked.Good for one-off projects: a store fix, an audit, a migration.Hard to budget for ongoing management. It rewards hours, not outcomes.
Fixed retainerThe same amount every month for a defined scope.Predictable for both sides. The agency can plan for the medium term.Read the scope carefully. If sales don't respond, you pay the same.
Percentage of ad spendThe agency charges a percentage of what you spend on ads.Grows with the account and is easy to calculate.The agency earns more when you spend more, even if that spend isn't profitable.
Performance or commissionThe agency takes a percentage of sales.Ties the agency to what you sell.Pin down the base: net Shopify sales or the sales each platform claims. With no monthly fee, few agencies can dedicate a stable team.
HybridA fixed monthly fee plus a variable part tied to results.Combines a stable team with an incentive to sell more.Check what triggers the variable part and how it's measured.

Always ask what the fee includes and what's billed separately: creative, store changes, apps and the ad spend itself.

What a fair contract includes

A fair contract protects both sides and can be read without a lawyer. Look for these in writing:

  • What gets delivered. The monthly scope of work, without generic phrases.
  • What you pay and how it's calculated. The fixed part, the variable part if there's one, and the exact formula.
  • How long it runs and how you leave. A reasonable initial commitment and a clear cancellation notice.
  • Who owns what. The store, the accounts, the creative and the data, including after it ends.
  • How ad spend is paid. Ideally straight from your card to each platform.
  • What gets reported and how often. With what data and in which meeting.

How to judge the first 90 days

Three months is enough to tell whether an agency does good work, even if it isn't always enough to see the full result. Judge what they did, not only what sold.

Month 1: cleanup and a baseline

Access set up in your name, tracking checked against Shopify orders, and an audit of the store and the campaigns. By the end of the month you should have a clear baseline: net sales, spend and starting ROAS.

Month 2: testing

A corrected campaign structure, new creative in testing and changes to the pages where sales drop off. You should be able to see what was tested and what was learned.

Month 3: the trend

Compare against the baseline: net Shopify sales, total ad spend and the ratio between them. What matters is the direction, and whether the agency can explain clearly what worked and what didn't.

Measure with your Shopify, not the report. Divide your net Shopify sales by total ad spend for the month. That number doesn't depend on how each platform claims credit for sales, and you can calculate it yourself.

When you don't need an agency yet

Sometimes the honest answer is to wait. You probably shouldn't hire management yet if:

  • You haven't validated the product. If there are no organic or word-of-mouth sales, ads only speed up the uncertainty.
  • Your margin can't carry advertising. If each sale leaves very little, fix price, costs and shipping first.
  • You can't sustain ad spend. Management with no budget to advertise has nothing to work with.
  • Your inventory can't support growth. Selling more than you can ship hurts the brand.

At that stage, a well-built store, tracking in order and small tests you can run yourself are usually enough. Our guides to Google Ads for Shopify and Amazon Ads for brands will help you get started.

How we work

So you have something to compare against, here's our model, one option among several. We've been in digital marketing since 2004 and in South Florida since 2011, and we're a Shopify Partner, a Google Partner and Meta certified.

Our main offer is the Growth Partnership, a hybrid model:

  • The store. New or redesigned on Shopify, delivered within one week of signing. It can be financed from $225 a month, depending on the term and what the lender approves.
  • Management. A fixed monthly fee from $1,500 a month for Meta, Google, store upkeep and a monthly report and meeting.
  • The commission. A percentage of net Shopify sales, charged only in months when your net Shopify sales reach 2.5 times your Meta and Google spend.

The initial commitment is 3 months; after that it's month to month with 30 days' notice. You pay ad spend directly to Meta and Google, and the store, the accounts and the data are yours.

What our clients sell

A sunglasses brand that started from zero in 2020 has reached $23.2 million in cumulative Shopify sales. Another store grew 36% over the previous year. Together, our clients sell more than $1.5 million a month online, and we're rated 5.0 on Google.

No guaranteed results: if sales don't reach 2.5 times your ad spend, you pay no commission that month.

FAQ

Questions about choosing a Shopify agency

How much does a Shopify agency cost?

It depends on the scope and the pricing model. A one-off project is billed by the hour or by the project. Ongoing management is usually a monthly fee, sometimes with a variable part. Always compare what each fee includes and what's extra.

Is a Shopify-focused agency better than a general one?

An agency that knows Shopify inside out understands the store, the apps and the tracking, and that shows in the ads. What matters most is that someone owns the store, the ads and the data as one system.

Should I give the agency my Shopify password?

There's no need. Shopify lets you give an agency collaborator access with the permissions you choose, without sharing your password. Meta and Google work the same way: the agency joins your accounts as a partner.

How long should I give an agency?

About three months to judge the work fairly. The first month goes to sorting out tracking and structure. If there's no clear baseline and no explanation of what was tested after 90 days, that's a bad sign.

What happens to my accounts if I switch agencies?

If they're in your name, nothing: you remove the old agency's access and give the new one access. That's why account ownership is the first thing to check.

Is a commission-based agency always better?

Not always. It aligns incentives, but what matters is which sales it's calculated on and what triggers it. A commission on the sales each platform claims isn't the same as one on your net Shopify sales.

Free audit

Want a second opinion on your store?

In a 30-minute call you get a straight answer on what to fix in your store, ads and numbers, and whether our agreement makes sense for you. If you're interested after that, we send a proposal with the exact numbers.

Find out what's holding your sales back. Free.

In 30 minutes you get the list of what we'd fix first. It's yours to keep, whether you work with us or not.

Free auditWhatsApp